When you run a social enterprise, every pound you earn has to stretch that little bit further – it must cover your costs and deliver real change for people or the planet. Demonstrating that change is no longer a ‘nice-to-have’. Funders, customers and commissioners increasingly expect credible evidence that your work does what it says on the tin. That is where social impact measurement comes in.
In this article we unpack what social impact measurement is, why it is indispensable for social enterprises and third sector organisations, and how you can get started – even if you have limited time and budget. We draw on lessons from the recent Just Enterprise Impact Measurement process, as well as general good practice for third sector organisations.
What Is Social Impact Measurement?
Social impact measurement is the systematic process of collecting, analysing and reporting information on the social, economic and environmental changes generated by an organisation’s activities.
- It focuses on outcomes (the changes that happen) rather than just outputs (the things you deliver).
- It looks at both positive and negative effects, intended and unintended.
- It combines quantitative data (numbers) with qualitative insight (stories and lived experience).
Think of it as the social‑value counterpart to a financial profit‑and‑loss account – a structured way of showing the difference you make.
Why It Matters
Mission management
A clear impact framework acts as a dashboard for your purpose. Tracking outcomes against your Theory of Change shows whether day‑to‑day activities still align with your mission, flags any early drift from that mission and provides evidence when you need to adjust course.
Funding and investment
Grant distributors such as the National Lottery Community Fund and investors like Social Investment Scotland increasingly expect a “line of sight” from spend to outcome. Providing robust evidence shortens due‑diligence cycles, secures higher award values and opens doors to outcomes‑based contracts under Scotland’s Procurement Reform Act 2014.
For example, The Robertson Trust’s Large Grants guidance emphasises that applicants must “share evidence of the impact, or planned impact” of their work: a requirement that several Just Enterprise alumni have been able to successfully fulfil, helping them to secure significant awards.
Strategic decisions
Impact data is essential business intelligence. Knowing which interventions deliver the greatest change per pound lets you scale what works and phase out activities that no longer add value.
Marketing and storytelling
Stories are memorable, but numbers give them weight. For example, being able to state “87% of programme graduates move into Fair Work within six months” can turn a marketing message or case study into a compelling proof‑point and also differentiate you from purely commercial competitors. Credible figures strengthen pitches to public‑sector commissioners and bolster social media engagement.
Accountability & transparency
Trustees, community members and staff expect honest feedback. Publishing impact results in annual reports satisfies OSCR reporting requirements and demonstrates that you are a learning organisation, not merely a delivery contractor. Internally, clear data boosts morale by showing teams the tangible difference their work makes.
Policy influence
Aggregated sector‑wide data shapes the narrative on what works in inclusive growth. Evidence from programmes like Just Enterprise feeds directly into Scottish Government initiatives such as the Social Enterprise Action Plan 2024–27, the Wellbeing Economy Monitor and Community Wealth Building pilots, helping ensure that policy is grounded in real‑world outcomes.
The Basics – A Four‑Step Cycle
Before highlighting the individual tools, it helps to picture the overall flow of a typical impact‑measurement process.
Think of it as a continuous feedback loop:
plan → measure → learn → act, then back to plan again.
Mastering this rhythm ensures that insights are captured in real time and fed straight into decision‑making.
Step 1: Plan
Key Questions:
- What problem are we addressing?
- What change do we expect?
Practical Tips
- Create a logic model or Theory of Change. Keep it to one page and include assumptions.
Step 2: Measure
Key Questions:
- How will we know change has happened?
- Which indicators are feasible to track?
Practical Tips
- Use a blend of quantitative (e.g. jobs created, carbon saved) and qualitative (interviews, testimonies) data.
Start with 5–7 core metrics.
Step 3: Analyse & Learn
Key Questions:
- What do the numbers and stories tell us?
- How reliable are our findings?
Practical Tips
- Hold quarterly learning meetings.
- Compare against baselines or industry benchmarks.
Step 4: Report & Act
Key Questions:
- Who needs to know?
- What decisions will we make?
Practical Tips
- Tailor the format (infographic, short film, funder dashboard).
- Close the loop by feeding insights into planning.
Choosing the Right Indicators
With the cycle sketched out, the next step is to decide what success looks like in practice. Indicators translate broad mission statements into concrete, observable signposts of progress. Aim for a balanced dashboard that covers economic, social, environmental and inclusion outcomes without overloading your team.
Good indicators are Relevant, Reliable and Proportionate. Below are examples commonly used by Scottish social enterprises:
| Outcome Area | Possible Indicators |
| Economic |
|
| Social |
|
| Environmental |
|
| Equality & Inclusion |
|
Bonus tip: Keep an eye on national frameworks such as Scotland’s National Performance Framework (NPF) and the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) for alignment.
Data Collection on a Shoestring
You don’t need a six‑figure evaluation budget to gather credible evidence. By embedding light‑touch methods into existing activities, even micro‑organisations can build a resilient data pipeline.
- Piggy‑back on existing touchpoints – add two outcome questions to your event feedback form.
- Use free tools: Google Forms, Microsoft 365, Typeform (basic tiers).
- Schedule brief phone calls or WhatsApp voice notes for qualitative follow‑up.
- Partner with local universities for student research projects.
- Rotate volunteer roles so data entry does not fall on one person.
Bonus tip: Prioritise regularity over perfection. Consistent quarterly data beats a glossy but one‑off survey every three years.
Analysing and Interpreting Your Findings
Data alone is just noise until you turn it into insight. A disciplined, hypothesis‑led approach to analysis helps uncover patterns, test assumptions and spark improvements.
- Clean your data first – remove duplicates, check for missing answers.
- Use simple descriptive statistics: averages, percentages, trend lines.
- Segment results (e.g. by gender, rural/urban, deprivation quintile) to spot equity gaps.
- Triangulate: where numbers dip, look at participant stories to understand why.
- Be honest about limitations – sample size, attribution challenges.
Common Pitfalls – and How to Avoid Them
Even seasoned evaluators slip up. Knowing the classic traps – and how to dodge them – will save you time, money and goodwill.
| Pitfall | How to Avoid |
| Measuring everything | Focus on the vital few metrics linked to your mission and strategy. |
| Relying solely on self‑reported data | Mix self‑report with objective data (e.g. HMRC payroll, energy bills). |
| Collecting but not using data | Build monthly mini‑reviews into staff meetings. |
| Over‑claiming impact | Acknowledge external factors and share learning, not just success stories. |
| Under‑resourcing the work | Allocate at least 5 % of project budgets to evaluation and learning. |
Emerging Trends
The impact‑measurement landscape never stands still. Below are developments worth watching – and piloting – over the next few years.
- Wellbeing Economy metrics – aligning enterprise impact with Scotland’s Wellbeing Economy Monitor.
- Digital data capture – chat‑bot surveys, SMS polling for hard‑to‑reach groups.
- Participatory evaluation – beneficiaries co‑designing indicators and analysis.
- Proxy valuation – using cost–benefit analysis or Social Return on Investment (SROI) to express outcomes in monetary terms, where appropriate.
Conclusion
Measuring impact is not about chasing vanity metrics or ticking funder boxes – it is about learning, improving and proving. Done well, it becomes a virtuous cycle that sharpens your mission, strengthens your funding position and ultimately deepens the difference you make to communities across Scotland.
Make the most of the free specialist Social Impact Measurement support and training available through Just Enterprise and start measuring what matters!
Next Steps
Register for fully-funded one-to-one support here:
Alternatively, check for upcoming dates for our popular social impact measurement course here or request access to our on-demand e-learning course here.